Why dont we investigate the July war?
Posted by N10452I read an earlier thread on the Israeli hearing sessions concerning the July war and how a Prime minister is on his way to resign ( supposebly) because of his failure to lead a war.
But it takes two to tango, and Hezbollah is the other party involved in that war, shouldnt we investigate the reasons behind their actions and put them into trial if their actions are not justified ??
I see overwhelmed HA members after the Winograd report, and how their militia was a political disaster for Olmert, fine let the Lebanese people decide what they think of HA as well ..
Lebanon LOST after the war, regardless of what HA thinks or not, there are numbers that speak for themselves.
Our economy is ruined for 10 years at least, our infrastructure needs at least 5 years to be repaired, our debt increased etc etc ..
Let HA convince us why they kidnapped those soldiers and not inform the government, why did they chose this timing, because if that Israeli report proved one thing, is that not only Israel was not preparing any war, it showed that the Israeli army commanders were incompetent and did not even have a backup plan for such wars .. And this proves HA wrong big time.
Search

Who posts here
Sections
- Home
Bashir Gemayel (32)
Caricatures (23)
Contributors (11)
Critiques (397)
Economical (5)
Editorials (229)
Ethics & Religion (34)
Events (76)
Gebran Tueni (8)
Humor (330)
Information (271)
LBC News (138)
Lebanon (1308)
Movies (42)
News (287)
Other (192)
Personal Opinions (148)
Political (810)
Political Islam (31)
Predictions (4)
Regional Politics (55)
Social (14)
World News & Politics (83)
Other LF Sites
Site Tools

Recent Comments
- Doc 1559: Elie Thank you sadiki. Rodge The only way to get our msg accros is to clean our media in good way. Dont ask me how cuz I dont know ! It is the media where you and I are spending a lot of time reading and...
Ra'fat: GE and Siemens are good buys, their stock is hammered due to their financial arms but will be part of the future energy transition since they produce and are leaders in wind energy etc… I would buy...
Elie H: Doc Ali Welcome back rafi2. I always read your comments on this blog, you are one of the few shiaa around who truly support aoun and because of that I respect you.
danny: Rima, You R right. I regressed. I should let the barking dogs go…. Cheers
Mickel: I’m putting all my investment money in “Forclosed” signs
Rima: Ya Danny shou beina ma 3ala asseiss you advised us not to answer some rubbish posts on this blog why are you falling in the trap? As for me, I took your advice literally and am not even reading some posts Cheers
ja3far: bass an advice Fuziad… dont make serious investments before the audits reports at the end of the year… salam
ja3far: wallah ya Fuziad it is little good for lebanon in the long run but very scary for other places…. can u see Dubai disapearing ?
Fuziyad: Bass la tamnak ja3far, am short up to my neck enjoying the show, but panic will stop soon and it will be great time to do some stock picking, am thinking about the obvious ones like apple or BNP paribas, may...
ja3far: my pleasure rodge my pleasure.. i respect your wide vision and knowledge salam
Related Entries
16 Comments. Add your own...
1. WHAT | May 2nd, 2007 at 5:46 am
I agree with this post, but there is not much to investigate… We all know they are guilty of initiating acts of war at the very least.
2. S.M.S. | May 2nd, 2007 at 6:25 am
Totally agree, as well as HA and the FPM being held accountable for the damage and loss caused by the sit-ins in Central Beirut.
3. lebanon | May 2nd, 2007 at 8:31 am
we all look forwards to a just investigation and later trial of whoever the investigation shows accountable ..let there be an investigation and then many heads will fall down ..those who pretend to be innocent angels and peace pigeons will show as devils and satans ..and we will know who’s who and what’s what..
another investigation that will rule out the need to investigate the sit-in would be the investigation about corruption that was the star on the lebanese political stage since the beginning of the 90’s…why are the lebanese indebted before they come to life ..
*”fine let the Lebanese people decide what they think of HA as well ..”fine ..does the word people here mean all people as in a general referundum or justy see what politicians or investigators think..
*Lebanon LOST after the war, regardless of what HA thinks or not, there are numbers that speak for themselves” sure lebanon lost after the july war like it lost after every civil war..casualities..destruction of buildings and infrastructure and numbers speak….actually, numbers have been speaking since a ton of years and nobody toiled to investigate and try to limit the numbers …all of a sudden, HA are proved responsible for the increasing debts and all the filth..true lebanon lost but only when the binoculars are those of 3meer peretz..blinded…loss and victory are far from numbers and using the one way perspective hurts but the ones who don’t want to c ..
*”Let HA convince us why they kidnapped those soldiers and not inform the government, why did they chose this timing”yes true ,still not convinced why they kidnapped the soldiers and will never be..HA has adopted the case of the lebanese captives in the israeli prisons long time ago..the lebanese government has assured that HA is a resistance and has the right to get back the captives and liberate the land by all possible means…and resistance act like hunters..no noise..and they neither inform the “birds” nor know when the chance will knock..they just grasp the opportunity when they see it serves their resistence aims..
*”if that Israeli report proved one thing, is that not only Israel was not preparing any war, it showed that the Israeli army commanders were incompetent and did not even have a backup plan for such wars” poor israelis..they were not preparing for the war..the israelis never forget the slam they got after the humiliation they got in 2000..and they ‘ve been preparing since then…HA is a danger for israelis and they always prepare to retaliate for that withdrawal..remeber what antoine la7d said after they had to withdraw”we were expecting to withdraw,but with honor..b sharaf” israel has always been a victor and having been forced to withdraw was a relapse..they had to revenge for a wasted honor..and alas they got more humiliation…and no honor..
*”this proves HA wrong big time.” maybe we shall leave this for the investigation to decide
4. Delta | May 2nd, 2007 at 8:44 am
ya man why we dont investigate before jullys war : kniset saydet il najjet ?
-Ramzi Irani , Pierre boulos , about the dam syrian iranian spys ………….???????????? jully war ???????? its a joke ya man ino bada investigation we all know that HA is the one who draged the whole region to the conflict
5. Get over it | May 2nd, 2007 at 5:24 pm
LEBANON :
Very very very impressive outstanding like usual ! Hands are clapping. Thx for your time.
6. Get over it | May 2nd, 2007 at 6:33 pm
It’s an extraordinary thing for an individual to make that kind of decision ( waging a war) . It just runs counter to everthing that we think about! Why did they do it? Is it really because of 2 poor soldiers? Tons of soldiers are dying daily during military training!! Till this day , zionist did not give the media any answers . The first rule of war is to know your enemy . You cannot defeat it if you dont know what motivates it and that is why israel lost this war !
This is a significant zionist strategic, KILL-DESTROY AND INVADE but hamdella they failed. It will happen again ,if the ground is not prepared very carefully and i have no doubt that the whole entire world will support their war against us ! I dont know if the americans plan was actually to destroy both lebanon and HA ,but this is the FAILURE result situations
yup failure after spending billions and billions of $$ on it ! What was really their gaols behind this fanatic war? What was their core? Never in the history , not even in the NAZi period , was these such a war like july’s war (destroying anything that moves)….
In conclusion , ISRAEL failed but to all its supporter in lebanon always remember saddam!! I recommend to you,even though most of you beleive that israel will leave us alone if HA disarme that the zionist have a dream to build (ISRAEL AL KOBRA). Go ahead and be united coz the ISRAELI revenge on its way but this time to wipe the holly lebanon including christians areas , FIKRKON ISRAEL NEMIT 3LA KHSSARA W HAL MARA SANIOURA RA7 BYIBKE DAM LAMAN USA TITIRKO AGAIN :d …Our education must be our weapons so we can do so , and our unity is the only escape otherwise long living RESISTANCE agaisnt the zionist imperialist terrorist! This my WHISTLEBLOWER for you coz the 500,00 israeli soldiers are getting ready for the revenge.Be united be lebanon.
7. 3awne ma7et | May 3rd, 2007 at 12:13 am
delta knissit saydit el najet ma3roufe min ma daroure n7a2i2 fiya
8. angela | May 3rd, 2007 at 6:44 am
Delta : Now you figured that christians in lebanon are 2 steps back at all the time? Ya 3yblchum bs 3la heke leaders bil saf al massi7eh .
Djuan : decent post , like always you mention good point but you paint them with black hatred color as well . Sob7ano allah kif bti7ke like your general , hek bsir3a you ARE always in rush , ana bwajihlak nassi7a akhawiye review your comment ! At this moment , i do have a question for you and i would like you to answer it for me ( honesly) … you mean 50,000 or 500,000 soldiers? Cuz bisara7a i was visiting my dentist for normal check-up w houweh kamenta khabarneh nafes al 7keyi as yours?!!!!!!!!! Btw my doctor is jewish as well . Law sama7et answer my question…50,000 or 500,000 ? Very strange person that you are….
9. WHAT | May 3rd, 2007 at 6:53 am
lebanon;
I agree with some of the things you said. However, you mentioned that even the government acknowledges Hizballah as a “resistance”. The problem with this statement is that, even if it’s true or not, it is not legitimate.
Which government are we speaking of??? The Syrian-backed Lahoud gov?? That’s not a government, That’s corruption. No democratic leader would accept a foreign-funded group to use his land as a battleground. If HA was democratic, they would have passed a bill to allow for possible release of prisoners.
7abibi, the real resistance is that which fights to keep Lebanon free of foreign influence, not a neighbor who has left us alone since 2000.
As I said in the beginning, we ALL know Hizballah’s guilty of starting a pointless war, which by-the-way WE so greatly lost.
10. lebanon | May 3rd, 2007 at 5:38 pm
WHAT..WHAT..WHAT..
mmmmmm…true what government are we referring to?has there been a single gov’t in lebanon that was not backed -specifically in the post Taif period,the second republic,anyway the case was never different b4..lebanon has lost its virginity long time ago being f****d 3ttale3 wennezel..so all gov’ts were illigitimate and corrupted..however,like all previous gov’ts seniora’s syrian backed gov’t won the confidence of the parliament and this confidence is believed to legitimatize any gov’t..
*”No democratic leader would accept a foreign-funded group ….”true..for that the gov’t that legitimatized resistance shall fund resistance groups to avoid external intervention and support..
*”If HA was democratic, they would have passed a bill to allow for possible release of prisoners.” gosh….issuing bills to free prisoners from israeli prisons will keep the captives there just one day after forever…yes ..tell the captives “ra7 l kteer w ba2i l 2leel ” the point in this conflict is that israel is pictured as an innocent white lamb and HB is the ferocious wolf…it’s not israel who has been defying the resolutions of the UN ..it’s not israel attacking with and without excuses..lots of captives have been detained in israeli prisons and were not released except by some deal ,and to be more clear when israel’s hand was twisted..when people are accustomed to a certain belief(in this case lebanon’s strength lies in its weakness and israel has always been a victor )they are totally immersed in this belief and never come out of it even when they can take the lead depending on their strength…like you say m3awwad 3la ssa7asee7..counting them but never retaliating..it’s time for us to get back our rights by force…just the way they were taken..sorry buddy our strength lies in our strength..and the time for recieving whips has fleed..
*”7abibi, the real resistance is that which fights to keep Lebanon free of foreign influence, not a neighbor who has left us alone since 2000. ” you too are 7abibi ..and in the horizon i see but leaders inviting foreign influence instead of picking their thorns with their own hands and cleaning up the mess they have caused ..we all know who invited syria into lebanon and why and we know as well who “backed” syria to come and stay in lebanon this long..now with shifting winds “the road to rome ” has diverted from 3njar to ..some other place..and under the very same twinkling titles:peace,back up,support,enforcing democracy,fighting terrorism..you mention it..
*”As I said in the beginning, we ALL know Hizballah’s guilty of starting a pointless war, which by-the-way WE so greatly lost.” let me ask who ALL and who WE …i would have definitely guessed the answer had i known that lebanon has been abridged to nearly half its population..on the other hand there are your partners in this country who believe that HA was not guilty and didn’t launch the war and that the war was not pointless..and they believe that lebanon didn’t lose the war…in their side you will possibly find some WHAT saying” as i said in the beginning,we ALL know Hizballah’s not guilty of starting a pointless war,which by-the-way WE so greatly won”
11. Delta | May 3rd, 2007 at 9:17 pm
Djuan : u are talking about isreal al kobra nsit the big syria al hilal il khasib .. walla mich arre bhayetak a book bzakrak ino SSNp and ba3ess have a dream called the big syria that includes lebanon jordan half of cyprus up too some shit try to see from all the sides mich min zewyeh wehde
12. Get over it | May 4th, 2007 at 6:52 am
Angela :
I wasnt going to answer your question coz simply i decided not to post here anymore for many reasons ,but since you have asked in good ways (law sama7et, your words) I am more more than happy to answer your simple question .
Presently , i dont have all the answers with regard to how we deal with israel and how we win victory over their LONG-TERM strategies and plans. But I do know what the recipe for defeat the lebanese soil is . It is capitulation,conciliation and UNITED new generations government coz simply our traditional leader are bunch of BASTARDS , mud bags full of hatred specialy 14th of march. Regarding your question , I meant 50000 and that’s all about it , lately the IDF are doing heavy duty training all across our border!! Also , your doctor could be right!
At last, there is only one way to free ourselves from this crisis - to continue to take the fight on the enemy , to call their bluff and to make them feel more pain than we fell and always be united at first. And make no mistake about it -we are fighting pure evil in 3YN 3LI2, TARI2 JDIDE, JULY WAR and elsewhere around lebanon. Not only should HA continue to fight this way, we must turn our allies loose ( friendly country ) on our side . We must learn the historical lessons , we must remember the july war day by day and minute by minute where the ISRAELI tyrant killed our sons, economy and country . Whether HA responsible or not , they did not have any right TO DESTROY our country !
Thank you angela , ma3 inik ma 7taramtine also but at least you are not trying to turn the table on my head . HEY RAJA3ET MY COMMENT THIS TIME :P….so i hope no grammar rules are in there :P.. Iza badik i can do french alot better
:P :P… Probably you are not going to hear from me anymore so take care…
13. WHAT | May 4th, 2007 at 7:24 am
lebanon;
First, I just want to say that I want to clarify my position; I don’t support Israel in any way. I support Israel as much as I support Syria/Iran. None have any right to meddle with our affairs.
We have had governments in the past that were legitimate if not, as close as you can get. The reason why so many people don’t remember them is because there are so quickly corrupted because of what… foreign influence. And what foreign influence is in Lebanon right now? Syria and Iran via Hizballah. There videos on the internet( I will gladly give the links) of the Iranian government discussing what Hizballah should do to stop the Saniura government from allowing an international tribunal to enter the country.
Also, I can’t argue that the government recognized Hizballah as a resistance but I can’t say that they didn’t either. Don’t forget that Lahoud, A Syrian-elected chief of state for Lebanon is still currently in power. In July, I was watching 24 hrs. I’ve seen interview after report after investigation and so on. Do you know what I noticed, and others have noticed I’m sure, is that Lahoud was in Baabda watching his country go inti chaos. And he did nothing, why? Because bachar told him to do nothing. You know who did do something, Saniura. I saw him, plead his case to the UN, US, Israel, and The Arab League. I saw this man cry for what his country had gone through. Do you remember what Hizballah did, they somehow concluded that they won??? Are you serious!?! That’s is ignorant and insulting to all Lebanese. We lost countrymen in the 1000’s, we got buried deeper in debt, our land was destroyed, and a greater divide between our own people. AND FOR WHAT??? Hizballah’s cause, freeing some captives who may or may not be Lebanese, alive, innocent, etc!!!
To answer your question, “WE” is the people who don’t want Syria, Israel, Iran, US, whoever in our house telling us what to do and how to live.
I have no partners who think Hizballah is innocent. That’s an ignorant statement, you don’t know who I support so how can you know my partners. Why don’t you clarify this for me and name them.The war was pointless because Hizballah has nothing to show for it except death and destruction.
“ALL know Hizballah’s not guilty of starting a pointless war,which by-the-way WE so greatly won”Ummmmmmmmmm…The only thing we as Lebanese gained was more debt, international embarrassment, and more instability. If that’s what you call a win, I would hate to see you lose.
14. lebanon | May 4th, 2007 at 10:40 am
dear WHAT
*”First, I just want to say that I want to clarify my position; I don’t support Israel in any way” ..and for this i say i never mentioned that you support israel..why do u squeeze yourself in a corner where u feel who opposes your opinion is categorizing you as israel supporter..
*”And what foreign influence is in Lebanon right now? Syria and Iran via Hizballah”..this depends on your definition of foreign influence..in lebanon there are contradicting interests of international and regional players:america,france,syria,iran..these are the most famous..the former two are interfering and the latter two as well…to cut ways on any internal sides let us reject any foreign influence whatever name it has,like enforcing democracy..as long as one side accepts or invites foreign intervention the other side will never be shy to call for some other counter intervention..the country is on the verge of a big downfall ,and stubborness will never lead us to the desired end..the policy of no victor no loser is the best to calm peolpe down and bring them back together…we are brothers and we don’t need strangers to solve our problems..
*”I saw this man cry for what his country had gone through”..u believe those tears stopped the war?come on…this is a man of money and such men have nothing but to cry when they think they are losing..
“We lost countrymen in the 1000’s, we got buried deeper in debt, our land was destroyed, and a greater divide between our own people. “..these losses you r mentioning were the same when the lebanese launched wars against each others..at that time brothers were at war and killing was even tougher and as barbaric..the lebanese had their guns directed to the chests of other lebanese and their cause was not lebanese..debt debt debt..the war increased the debt but why was the debt there originally?again was it for a lebanese cause…b4 the war the suffering was high..more debts less services or low quality services..more debts and no employment..more debt and more immigration..more debt and more negative things..and no audit..those who are now sticking to the chairs have long been indulged in increasig the debt without any restraint or being questioned..why this emphasis that HA increased the debt without any effect to uproot the debt problem?
*”Hizballah’s cause, freeing some captives who may or may not be Lebanese, alive, innocent, etc!!!”may or maynot be lebanese ..u doubt the lebanonity of samir kuntar,nassim nesr and ye7ya skaf..they are alive as they live in the conscious of all the lebanese people just like the lebanese detainees in any other prison….innocent?let a fair trial decide on this..if they would be convicted that would be for teh crime of resistance ..
“To answer your question, “WE” is the people who don’t want Syria, Israel, Iran, US, whoever in our house telling us what to do and how to live.”
so let me say i belong to this WE(though we might not meet when it comes to details) ..all interferences have screwed up our life and unity..will we live to see a free independent country?
*”I have no partners who think Hizballah is innocent”..this sounds like confiscating lebanon for yourself..shall i remind you that all lebanese are partners in this country ..true they have different opinions but they still share a life and a “watan” or remnant of a watan..on the other hand there migt be HBers who see other politicians or parties as criminal and not innocent..it’s a point of view..so different opinios shall not ruin relations..
*”you don’t know who I support so how can you know my partners.”i needn’t know who you support to know who your partners are..i just am sure you are LEBANESE and for me this is more than enough to know that all other LEBANESE are your partners..a brother might some time be off the track ,but his brothser are always there to guide him back..if you see that other lebanese have lost the way just exert little effort and bring them back..it’s worth a try..
*”The war was pointless because Hizballah has nothing to show for it except death and destruction.”some incidents or events are underestimated bcoz we just calculate the results on the short run..on the short run the july war brought destruction and death..the crop will soon yield and we will all enjoy the harvest..you can here keep sarcasm for a later time as to the long run results..hopefully things will be settled b4 you run out of patience ..
*”ALL know Hizballah’s not guilty of starting a pointless war,which by-the-way WE so greatly won”..i’ll reput it in the original context[in their side you will possibly find some WHAT saying” as i said in the beginning,we ALL know Hizballah’s not guilty of starting a pointless war,which by-the-way WE so greatly won]..this was in my former reply..i assumed that if you would hear this from anybody you will say:5tassaro lebnan b 7alon ..mish haik ra2yi ana..so my point was not to generalize your opinions ..definitely some other lebanese don’t share your opinion ..and everybody shall respect multiplicity..
best regards
15. WHAT | May 5th, 2007 at 5:20 am
Dear lebanon;
Firstly, I didn’t feel “squeezed into a corner” on those who oppose my opinion. With that said, you’ve just admitted to me with this comment that you have a biased reflection of views. So no matter what I say, you will oppose. “Those” who oppose me? the only person opposing me is YOU. I don’t oppose you I simply don’t agree with you.
Now let me properly respond:
You spoke of other regional influences involved in Lebanon. Tell me, which other country currently supports, funds, arms, and trains people in Lebanon to go to war the country’s government. I’ll take the ones you mentioned.
France: Supports the Saniura government of Lebanon. They involve themselves democratically. They don’t smuggle weapons into Lebanon and train terrorists to muscle out anyone who doesn’t agree with them. All they want is to see their friends live peacefully and freely. Evacuated 1000’s of Lebanese and French Lebanese from Lebanon for free.
America(US): Supports the Saniura government. After the July crisis, They provided the LAF with $100,000 in weapons, ammunition, and armored vehicles. Also, provided Lebanese soldiers with military training. Sent by air food, medication and supplies, and water to Lebanese victims regardless of their political affiliation. Evacuated 10’s of 1000’s of Lebanese-Americans and Lebanese for free.
Syria: Elected our president for us. Smuggles Weapons to Hizballah to fight Israel from Lebanon because they are too cowardly to fight them face to face. In the July war, they offered no aid, but told Israel not to come too close to Syria or else.
Iran: Supports, funds, arms, trains a radical group that is not parallel to the government. Continues to give orders to Hizballah to launch scheduled attacks on Israel when they get politically pressured by the international community. Constantly working to make the Islamic Revolution in Lebanon a reality. During the July war, they sent a diplomat to visit hospitals in Lebanon.
What you said:
“let us reject any foreign influence whatever name it has,like enforcing democracy”
-Enforcing democracy?? We want democracy!!! Without order there is either chaos or dictatorship.
What you said:
“we are brothers and we don’t need strangers to solve our problems..”
-I agree, So why does Hizballah exist? They chant “al mout li amrika” and praise Syria and Iran. Why do they not Praise Lebanon.
What you said:
“come on…this is a man of money and such men have nothing but to cry when they think they are losing..”
-You come on!!! What was Hassan Nasrallah doing when our country was being destroyed? Where was he?
All I’m going to say about your reply to my comment about debt is that your response is weak and a cop-out. What happened last July destroyed everything we worked so hard to rebuild from the civil war. Hizballah’s actions single handedly brought Lebanon back 20 years at least.
What you said:
“..u doubt the lebanonity of samir kuntar,nassim nesr and ye7ya skaf..they are alive as they live in the conscious of all the lebanese people just like the lebanese detainees in any other prison….innocent?let a fair trial decide on this..if they would be convicted that would be for teh crime of resistance ..”
-You dare show pride when you speak of Samir Kuntar. The man who walked into a random home in Israel murdered a family and was proud to say he killed an innocent child. Your definition of resistance is known as deplorable murder everywhere else in the world.
“i needn’t know who you support to know who your partners are..i just am sure you are LEBANESE and for me this is more than enough to know that all other LEBANESE are your partners..a brother might some time be off the track ,but his brothser are always there to guide him back..if you see that other lebanese have lost the way just exert little effort and bring them back..it’s worth a try..”
-That’s exactly what I’m trying to do. I want all Hizballah supporters to know my family has been through real resistances in the past and if they want to be part of a real resistance today, reject Syria and Iran, Israel, and anyone else. You said this yourself, so stop saying it and start doing it.
“on the short run the july war brought destruction and death..the crop will soon yield and we will all enjoy the harvest..you can here keep sarcasm for a later time as to the long run results..hopefully things will be settled b4 you run out of patience ..”
-There is nothing to harvest from this war but depression, disappointment, shame anger, and confusion, short or long term. Long term, I can guarantee Hizballah will use this event as a catalyst to fuel anger towards Israel the next time they want to skirmish. But they will leave out the part where they were the reason why Israel bombed us.
“i assumed that if you would hear this from anybody you will say:5tassaro lebnan b 7alon ..mish haik ra2yi ana..so my point was not to generalize your opinions ..definitely some other lebanese don’t share your opinion ..and everybody shall respect multiplicity..”
-What Hizballah is doing in Lebanon is not right and I won’t hesitate to say it. Kil hizb bi libnan bi zaghir el balad. Bas mish kil hizb bi zaghir balado w bi dabi7 sha3b balado la 7ata zaw2u bi2wa. I know you don’t share my view,. I said others, not ALL, share my views and dream for a free independent democratic Lebanon.
Inshallah bil mustqbal, watana ma3sh bysma3 saut il harb.
16. lebanon | May 5th, 2007 at 11:02 am
dear WHAT
you opened your former comment with trying to aquit yourself of an accusation that nobody has blamed you of “i don’t support israel in any way”..so i just wonderd why you put yourself in defense position….
as of opposing you ,i wonder why you have interpeted it aggressively..i definitely mean not agree on some points,though that ,i hope ,wouldn’t negatively affect us..
*i spoke of other influences and i believe that the structure of the lebanese community is some kind of sensitive ..any “support”will be interpreted as a nourishment of one side at the cost of the other which will create some feeling of enmity..
whether they interfere democratically or not,why shall we always categorize ourselves as minors needing custody..the political paralysis we see now is mainly caused by the refusal to compromise..both sides are clinging to their demands and noone is ready for a compromise..so how will things be done?
some in lebanon believe that what you call french and american friendly support is mere interference that will lead to more chaos..similarly,what you see as iranian or syrian interference is support for others..so my point is to stop depending on these countries to solve our problems..it’s time to do it ourselves..we just need the will..
*as to syria has elected our president ,this has been the course of things since presidents have been elected in lebanon..this is the part of the fact…the other part is that syria has never elected the president ,in addition to all other interferences,except with the blessing of the US and particularly what ambassador abdalla bu 7abibi calls “the yellow light” from america..
*as to july war you seem much concerned about the losses in lives,the destruction and the more debts that the war caused..these happen to be myt concersns as well..however,the same friendly america who sent medical aid and evacuated those who wanted to leave for free ,this same america has supported israel with the destructive weaponry,with cluster bombs ammunitions that israel used to destroy lebanon and kill its people..this same america has extended the period of the war urging israel to drown more in the lebanese swamp ..just to get rid of the terrorist party..had they?in the july war none of these facts is highlighted..it’s only HB who launched the war and caused the losses..
what i said is that let us refuse any interference regardless of the announced aims of that interference,even if the announced aim were to enforce democracy..we definitely want democracy but we don’t want any external forces to teach us democracy when they don’t even apply it at home..why do we always have to enjoy the role of the weak victim who needs aid and support..the age of maturity is 18 and sometimes 21…has lebanon not celebrated its 21st birthday..applying democracy needs no more than an internal will and necessary awareness..i surely have never refused democracy and i am fed up with this chaos..
*yes tell me what nasralla was doing when the war was destroying lebanon..he definitely was in some spa succumbing to massage sessions to lessen his stress..smoking argili..enjoying friends company..laughing at the scenes of destruction transferred to him via sattelites in his luxurious villa..welcoming irani and syrian messengers to get their messages on how to extend the war..and in his free time he was playing lee5a..and when he had time to remember he was asking himself:”why did i send my son to fight against the israelis in response to regional agenda..i could’ve sent him to US or to france..he would’ve surely met some lebanese buddies..sons of political leaders ..they would have surely been enjoying their time..”
*for the debt let there be an audit and let all those who contributed to corruption and to increasing the size of debt starting HB back till all corrupts be brought to a trail that will empty their pockets of the money they’ve swallowed in the name of rebuilding lebanon and cleaning the mess of the civil war..
*samir kuntar is not lebanese because he killeed and horrified an innocent family in what some lebanese consider an act of resistance…cool..what about a suggestion to declare not lebanese all these who killed innocent people during the civil war ,before and after…..do i hear you say it was a state of war and things were justified?i don’t know why we always have to sympathize with our enemy and show them as innocent lamb..kuntar is not lebanese bcoz he killed some israelis..3baas mousawi ,ragheb 7arb,ghaleb 3wali and others are not lebanese bcoz israel killed them..so the criterion in classification is what suits the enemy ..israel keeps asking for the corpses of its dead soldiers or spies even when they have caused harm to innocent people..we shall respect their will in killing and keeping our people bcoz they are always right..
*”if they want to be part of a real resistance today, reject Syria and Iran, Israel, and anyone else. You said this yourself, so stop saying it and start doing it.”
this is what you said and this is what i believe ..plus,i will replace ” if they want” with “if anyone wants” …reject syria,iran,israel and anyone else..exactly all these and anyone else..u said this so let us start doing it..
*definitely you and others have the right to say what HB is doing is not right..definitely there are others who say this..and definitely there are others who say what musta2bal is doing is not right or what LFrs are doing is not right..it’s a free country..it’s our country..and what is lovely about it is that we live together and shall 4ever do..
i add my voice to your last prayer and i say AMEN..
Please Wait
Leave a Reply
Trackback this post | Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed